Question

考虑到多个问题excellent_informative_for_me - trashgod的回答，that和that以及其他几个不回答我问题的问题，
如何设计一个关于ActionListeners位置的类
（以及整体MVC分离 - 更多解释如下）。

1。问题解释

我读过关于MVC的内容，我认为我理解了大部分内容，让我们假设这是真的，为了这个问题。不详细说明：

根据控制器请求，从模型生成视图在大多数实现中，View可以访问Model实例。
Controller与用户交互，将更改传播到Model和View。
模型极其简化，是数据的容器它可以通过View观察到。

现在，我的困惑与ActionListeners有关 - 哪个类应该注册 - 反过来也包含 - 按钮的代码，或者实际上是大多数View元素的代码，它们实际上不仅仅是指标，而是模型操纵器？

假设我们在视图中有两个项目 - 按钮可更改模型数据，而某些视觉项目仅用于更改视图外观。让代码负责在View类中更改View外观似乎是合理的。我的问题与第一个案件有关。我有几个想法：

View创建按钮，因此在View中创建ActionListeners并同时注册回调是很自然的。 但这要求View拥有与模型相关的代码，打破封装。 View应该只知道底层的Controller或Model，只能通过Observer与它交谈。
我可以公开View项目，比如按钮等，并从Controller，将ActionListeners附加到它们，但这又打破了封装。
我可以为每个按钮实现一些回调 - View会询问控制器是否有任何代码应该注册为给定按钮名称的ActionListener但这看起来过于复杂，并且需要同步控制器和视图之间的名称。
我可以假设，理智;），TableFactory中的按钮可能会公开，允许将ActionListeners注入任何代码。
控制器可以替换整个View项目（创建按钮并替换现有项目）但这看起来很疯狂，因为它不是它的角色

2。我的例子（4）

.
└── test
    ├── controllers
    │   └── Controller.java
    ├── models
    │   └── Model.java
    ├── resources
    │   └── a.properties
    ├── Something.java
    └── views
        ├── TableFactory.java
        └── View.java

3。编译/清除源代码（4）

编译：

javac test / Something.java test / models / * .java test / controllers / * .java test / views / * .java

使用以下命令运行：

java test.Something

清洁：

找到。 -iname“* .class”-exec rm {} \;

4。来源

此代码还包含国际化存根，为此我提出了单独的问题，这些行已明确标记，不应对答案产生任何影响。

package test.controllers;
import test.models.Model;
import test.views.View;
public class Controller {
// Stub - doing nothing for now.
}

package test.models;
import java.util.Observable;
public class Model extends Observable {
}

package test;

import test.views.View;
import test.models.Model;
import test.controllers.Controller;

public class Something {

    Model m;
    View v;
    Controller c;

    Something() {
        initModel();
        initView();
        initController();
    }

    private void initModel() {
        m = new Model();
    }

    private void initView() {
        v = new View(m);
    }
    private void initController() {
        c = new Controller(m, v);
    }

    public static void main(String[] args) {
        javax.swing.SwingUtilities.invokeLater(new Runnable() {
            public void run() {
                Something it = new Something();
            }
        });
    }
}

package test.views;

import java.awt.*;              // layouts
import javax.swing.*;           // JPanel

import java.util.Observer;      // MVC => model
import java.util.Observable;    // MVC => model
import test.models.Model;       // MVC => model

import test.views.TableFactory;

public class View {

    private JFrame root;
    private Model model;
    public JPanel root_panel;

    public View(Model model){
        root = new JFrame("some tests");
        root.setDefaultCloseOperation(JFrame.EXIT_ON_CLOSE);
        root_panel = new JPanel();

        root_panel.add(new TableFactory(new String[]{"a", "b", "c"}));

        this.model = model;
        this.model.addObserver(new ModelObserver());

        root.add(root_panel);
        root.pack();
        root.setLocationRelativeTo(null);
        root.setVisible(true);
    }
}

class ModelObserver implements Observer {

    @Override
    public void update(Observable o, Object arg) {
        System.out.print(arg.toString());
        System.out.print(o.toString());
    }
}

package test.views;

import java.awt.*;
import java.awt.event.*;
import java.util.*;
import javax.swing.*;
import javax.swing.table.DefaultTableModel;

public class TableFactory extends JPanel {

    private String[] cols;
    private String[] buttonNames;
    private Map<String, JButton> buttons;
    private JTable table;

    TableFactory(String[] cols){

        this.cols = cols;
        buttonNames = new String[]{"THIS", "ARE", "BUTTONS"};
        commonInit();
    }
    TableFactory(String[] cols, String[] buttons){

        this.cols = cols;
        this.buttonNames = buttons;
        commonInit();
    }

    private void commonInit(){

        this.buttons = makeButtonMap(buttonNames);
        DefaultTableModel model = new DefaultTableModel();
        this.table = new JTable(model);
        for (String col: this.cols)
            model.addColumn(col);

        setLayout(new BoxLayout(this, BoxLayout.PAGE_AXIS));

        JPanel buttons_container = new JPanel(new GridLayout(1, 0));
        for (String name : buttonNames){
            buttons_container.add(buttons.get(name));
        }

        JScrollPane table_container = new JScrollPane(table);

        this.removeAll();
        this.add(buttons_container);
        this.add(table_container);
        this.repaint();
    }

    private Map<String, JButton> makeButtonMap(String[] cols){
        Map<String, JButton>  buttons = new HashMap<String, JButton>(cols.length);
        for (String name : cols){
            buttons.put(name, new JButton(name));
        }
        return buttons;
    }
}

编辑（回应下面的评论）

下一个信息来源here

经过一番思考之后，我理解了Olivier的评论以及后来的Hovercraft充满了鳗鱼的细节... javax.swing.Action =＆gt; setAction是我的方式。 Controller访问View的JPanels，获取对包含按钮或任何JComponent的映射的引用，并为其添加操作。 View不知道Controllers代码中的内容。

只有两件令我担心的事情（两者都非常罕见，但仍然存在）：

因为我将View的添加动作公开的方法，实际上我相信任何人只能从控制器或视图添加它。但如果该模型可以访问视图 - 它也可以覆盖操作。
也是压倒性的。如果我设置一些对象的动作，然后忘记并从不同的地方设置另一个动作，它就会消失，这可能会使调试变得困难。

Answer 1

虽然Model–View–Controller模式为no panacea，但是Swing应用程序设计中的循环模式。如上所述here，Swing控件组件通常是视图包含层次结构的一部分：Swing应用程序的控制器几乎没什么可做的，只是将这些组件连接到相关的监听器; Action的实例，其中＆＃34;可用于将功能和状态与组件分开，＆＃34;特别方便。在这个example中，重置处理程序（一个简单的ActionListener）嵌套在控制器中，但它也可以作为{{1}从模型中导出}。正如建议here，您可能需要尝试不同的设计。引用了几种方法here。

Answer 2

虽然@trashgod的回答总结并扩展到评论的某种程度的讨论，但我发布了基于该讨论的丑陋（但工作）解决方案（在Controller类中实现Action）

有什么变化？

TableFactory - 已添加public void setObjectAction(Action a, JButton b)并允许公开访问Map<String, JButton> buttons
Controller类需要实现AbstractAction或从中继承的类，以及将此类的对象设置为View的深层嵌套JComponent的代码。我发现那部分非常难看，而且我不确定这种方法是否合理，或者是否有更好的解决方案（将在稍后检查气垫船中充满鳗鱼豆）。
我不需要进行任何其他更改但我稍微修改了View.java以稍微更好地显示此问题的目的，或者以不同的方式显示（这使得View.java比MCVE更多，但恕我直言更好地描述了目的）

TableFactory.java

package test.views;

import java.awt.*;
import java.awt.event.*;
import java.util.*;
import javax.swing.*;
import javax.swing.table.DefaultTableModel;
import javax.swing.Action;

public class TableFactory extends JPanel {

    private String[] cols;
    private String[] buttonNames;
    public Map<String, JButton> buttons;
    private JTable table;

    TableFactory(String[] cols){
        this.cols = cols;
        buttonNames = new String[]{"some", "buttons"};
        commonInit();
    }
    TableFactory(String[] cols, String[] buttons){

        this.cols = cols;
        this.buttonNames = buttons;
        commonInit();
    }

    private void commonInit(){

        this.buttons = makeButtonMap(buttonNames);

        DefaultTableModel model = new DefaultTableModel();
        this.table = new JTable(model);
        for (String col: this.cols)
            model.addColumn(col);

        setLayout(new BoxLayout(this, BoxLayout.PAGE_AXIS));

        JPanel buttons_container = new JPanel(new GridLayout(1, 0));
        for (String name : buttonNames){
            buttons_container.add(buttons.get(name));
        }

        JScrollPane table_container = new JScrollPane(table);

        this.removeAll();
        this.add(buttons_container);
        this.add(table_container);
        this.repaint();
    }

    private Map<String, JButton> makeButtonMap(String[] cols){
        Map<String, JButton>  buttons = new HashMap<String, JButton>(cols.length);
        for (String name : cols){
            buttons.put(name, new JButton(name));
        }
        return buttons;
    }

    public void setObjectAction(Action a, JButton b){
        //it might be possible to set actions to something else than button, I imagine JComponent, but I havent figured out yet how
        b.setAction(a);
    }
}

View.java

package test.views;

import java.awt.*;              // layouts
import javax.swing.*;           // JPanel

import java.util.Observer;      // MVC => model
import java.util.Observable;    // MVC => model
import test.models.Model;       // MVC => model

import test.views.TableFactory;

public class View {

    private JFrame root;
    private Model model;
    public JPanel root_panel;
    public JPanel some_views[];

    public View(Model model){
        root = new JFrame("some tests");
        root.setDefaultCloseOperation(JFrame.EXIT_ON_CLOSE);
        root_panel = new JPanel();

        some_views = new JPanel[] { 
                       new TableFactory(new String[]{"a", "b", "c"}),
                       new TableFactory(new String[]{"e", "e"}) };
        JTabbedPane tabs = new JTabbedPane();
        for (JPanel tab: some_views){
            String name = tab.getClass().getSimpleName();
            tabs.addTab(name, null, tab, name);
            //tab.setObjectAction(action, (JComponent) button); // can set internal 'decorative' View's action here, that are not interacting with Model
            // for example, add new (empty) row to JTable, as this does not modify Model (yet)
        }
        root_panel.add(tabs);


        this.model = model;
        this.model.addObserver(new ModelObserver());

        root.add(root_panel);
        root.pack();
        root.setLocationRelativeTo(null);
        root.setVisible(true);
    }
}

class ModelObserver implements Observer {

    @Override
    public void update(Observable o, Object arg) {
        System.out.print(arg.toString());
        System.out.print(o.toString());
    }
}

Controller.java

package test.controllers;

import test.models.Model;
import test.views.View;


import javax.swing.Action;
import java.awt.event.*;
import test.views.TableFactory;
import javax.swing.*;

public class Controller {
    private Model model;
    private View view;
    public Controller(Model model, View view){
        this.model = model;
        this.view = view;

        ((test.views.TableFactory)view.some_views[0]).setObjectAction(
            (Action) new ModelTouchingAction("move along, nothing here"),
            ((test.views.TableFactory)view.some_views[0]).buttons.get("FIRST") );
    }

    class ModelTouchingAction extends AbstractAction { 
        public ModelTouchingAction(String text) {
            super(text);
        }
        public void actionPerformed(ActionEvent e) {
            System.out.print("Invoked: " + e.toString());
        }
    }
}

Answer 3

工作版本，压缩到单个Something.java文件使用javac Something.java && java Something

运行

import java.util.*;
import java.util.Observer;
import java.util.Observable;
import java.awt.*;
import java.awt.event.*;
import javax.swing.*;
import javax.swing.table.DefaultTableModel;

class Controller {
    private enum TYPE { RESET, ADD, DEL };
    private Model model;
    private View view;
    public Controller(Model model, View view){
        this.model = model;
        this.view = view;
        ((TableFactory) view.tf).setObjectAction(
            (Action) new ModelTouchingAction("reset*",TYPE.RESET),
            "BUTTON1" );
        ((TableFactory) view.tf).setObjectAction(
            (Action) new ModelTouchingAction("add*",TYPE.ADD),
            "BUTTON2" );
        ((TableFactory) view.tf).setObjectAction(
            (Action) new ModelTouchingAction("del*",TYPE.DEL),
            "BUTTON3" );
    }

    class ModelTouchingAction extends AbstractAction {
        private TYPE t;
        public ModelTouchingAction(String text, TYPE type) {
            super(text);
            this.t = type;
        }
        public void actionPerformed(ActionEvent e) {
            if(this.t == TYPE.ADD)
                model.add();
            else if(this.t == TYPE.DEL)
                model.del();
            else
                model.reset();
        }
    }
}

class Model extends Observable {
    private ArrayList<String[]> data;
    private static int cnt = 0;
    Model(){ reset(); }
    public void reset(){
        data = new ArrayList<String[]>();
        data.add(new String[]{"cell a1", "cell a2", "cell a3"});
        data.add(new String[]{"cell b1", "cell b2", "cell b3"});
        info();
    }
    public void add(){
        cnt++;
        data.add(new String[]{String.valueOf(cnt++), 
                 String.valueOf(cnt++), String.valueOf(cnt++)});
        info();
    }
    public void del(){
        if (data.size()>0){
            data.remove(data.size() - 1);
            info();
        }
    }
    private void info(){ setChanged();  notifyObservers(); }
    public ArrayList<String[]> get(){ return data; }
}

public class Something {

    Model m;
    View v;
    Controller c;
    Something() {
        initModel();
        initView();
        initController();
    }

    private void initModel() {
        m = new Model();
    }
    private void initView() {
        v = new View(m);
    }
    private void initController() {
        c = new Controller(m, v);
    }

    public static void main(String[] args) {
        javax.swing.SwingUtilities.invokeLater(new Runnable() {
            public void run() {
                Something it = new Something();
            }
        });
    }
}

class View {

    private JFrame root;
    private Model model;
    public JPanel root_panel;
    public TableFactory tf;

    public View(Model model){
        root = new JFrame("some tests");
        root.setDefaultCloseOperation(JFrame.EXIT_ON_CLOSE);
        root_panel = new JPanel();
        tf = new TableFactory(new String[]{"col1", "col2", "col3"});
        root_panel.add(tf);

        this.model = model;
        this.model.addObserver(new ModelObserver(tf));

        root.add(root_panel);
        root.pack();
        root.setLocationRelativeTo(null);
        root.setVisible(true);
    }
}

class ModelObserver implements Observer {
    TableFactory tf;
    ModelObserver(TableFactory tf){ this.tf = tf; }
    @Override
    public void update(Observable o, Object arg) {
        if (null != o)
            this.tf.populate(((Model) o).get());
            // view reloads ALL from model, optimize it
            // check what to check to get CMD from Observable
        else
            System.out.print("\nobservable is null");
        if (null != arg)
            System.out.print(arg.toString());
        else
            System.out.print("\narg is null. No idea if it should be.");
    }
}

class TableFactory extends JPanel {

    private String[] cols;
    public String[] buttonNames;
    private Map<String, JButton> buttons;
    private JTable table;

    TableFactory(String[] cols){

        this.cols = cols;
        buttonNames = new String[]{"BUTTON1", "BUTTON2", "BUTTON3"};
        commonInit();
    }
    TableFactory(String[] cols, String[] buttons){

        this.cols = cols;
        this.buttonNames = buttons;
        commonInit();
    }

    private void commonInit(){

        this.buttons = makeButtonMap(buttonNames);
        DefaultTableModel tabModel = new DefaultTableModel();
        this.table = new JTable(tabModel);
        for (String col: this.cols)
            tabModel.addColumn(col);

        setLayout(new BoxLayout(this, BoxLayout.PAGE_AXIS));

        JPanel buttons_container = new JPanel(new GridLayout(1, 0));
        for (String name : buttonNames){
            buttons_container.add(buttons.get(name));
        }

        JScrollPane table_container = new JScrollPane(table);

        this.removeAll();
        this.add(buttons_container);
        this.add(table_container);
        this.repaint();
    }
    public void populate(ArrayList<String[]> data){
        ((DefaultTableModel) table.getModel()).setRowCount(0);
        for(String[] row:data) addRow(row); 
    }
    private void addRow(String[] row){
        ((DefaultTableModel) table.getModel()).addRow(row);
        // this is actually called only by populate, model does not have single 
        // row update here (and onUpdate ModelObserver cannot differentiate 
        // yet what method to call on Observable, TODO: check CMD? )
    }
    private void delRow(int rowID){
        System.out.print("\nJPanel should be deleting table row " + rowID);
    }
    public void setObjectAction(Action action, String buttonName){
        buttons.get(buttonName).setAction(action);
    }
    private Map<String, JButton> makeButtonMap(String[] cols){
        Map<String, JButton>  buttons = new HashMap<String, JButton>(cols.length);
        for (String name : cols){
            buttons.put(name, new JButton(name));
        }
        return buttons;
    }
}

java swing mvc architecture - 带有MCVE示例的

TOC