Guile Scheme解释器中的奇怪乘法行为

时间:2013-01-24 07:01:00

标签: scheme mit-scheme guile

我在OS X的Guile 1.8.8翻译中练习Scheme。我注意到了一些有趣的事情。

这是expt函数,它基本上是取幂expt(b,n) = b^n

 (define (square x) (* x x))
 (define (even? x) (= (remainder x 2) 0))
 (define (expt b n) 
      (cond ((= n 0) 1)
        ((even? n) (square (expt b (/ n 2))))
        (else (* b (expt b (- n 1))))
      ))

如果我尝试一些输入

 > (expt 2 10)
 1024
 > (expt 2 63)
 9223372036854775808

这是一个奇怪的部分:

 > (expt 2 64)
 0

更奇怪的是,直到n=488保持0

 > (expt 2 487)
 0
 > (expt 2 488)
 79916762888089401123.....
 > (expt 2 1000)
 1071508607186267320948425049060....
 > (expt 2 10000)
 0

当我使用repl.it在线解释器尝试此代码时,它按预期工作。那么 Guile 到底出了什么问题?

(注意:在某些方言中,remainder函数被称为mod。)

3 个答案:

答案 0 :(得分:36)

我最近在{Guile 2.0} fixed这个错误。当C编译器开始优化溢出检查时,该错误就出现了,理论上如果发生有符号整数溢出,则行为未指定,因此编译器可以做任何喜欢的事情。

答案 1 :(得分:11)

我可以在OS X上用guile 2.0.6重现这个问题。它归结为:

> (* 4294967296 4294967296)
$1 = 0

我的猜测是,guile使用native int类型来存储小数字,然后切换到bignums,当本机int太小时,由GNU MP支持。也许在那种特殊情况下,检查失败,计算溢出了native int。

有趣的是,以下循环显示2 ^ 32和2 ^ 60之间的平方幂为2:

(let loop
    ((x 1)
     (exp 0))
  (format #t "(2^~s) ^ 2 = ~s\n" exp (* x x))
  (if (< exp 100)
      (loop (* 2 x) (+ 1 exp))))

结果:

(2^0) ^ 2 = 1
(2^1) ^ 2 = 4
(2^2) ^ 2 = 16
(2^3) ^ 2 = 64
(2^4) ^ 2 = 256
(2^5) ^ 2 = 1024
(2^6) ^ 2 = 4096
(2^7) ^ 2 = 16384
(2^8) ^ 2 = 65536
(2^9) ^ 2 = 262144
(2^10) ^ 2 = 1048576
(2^11) ^ 2 = 4194304
(2^12) ^ 2 = 16777216
(2^13) ^ 2 = 67108864
(2^14) ^ 2 = 268435456
(2^15) ^ 2 = 1073741824
(2^16) ^ 2 = 4294967296
(2^17) ^ 2 = 17179869184
(2^18) ^ 2 = 68719476736
(2^19) ^ 2 = 274877906944
(2^20) ^ 2 = 1099511627776
(2^21) ^ 2 = 4398046511104
(2^22) ^ 2 = 17592186044416
(2^23) ^ 2 = 70368744177664
(2^24) ^ 2 = 281474976710656
(2^25) ^ 2 = 1125899906842624
(2^26) ^ 2 = 4503599627370496
(2^27) ^ 2 = 18014398509481984
(2^28) ^ 2 = 72057594037927936
(2^29) ^ 2 = 288230376151711744
(2^30) ^ 2 = 1152921504606846976
(2^31) ^ 2 = 4611686018427387904
(2^32) ^ 2 = 0
(2^33) ^ 2 = 0
(2^34) ^ 2 = 0
(2^35) ^ 2 = 0
(2^36) ^ 2 = 0
(2^37) ^ 2 = 0
(2^38) ^ 2 = 0
(2^39) ^ 2 = 0
(2^40) ^ 2 = 0
(2^41) ^ 2 = 0
(2^42) ^ 2 = 0
(2^43) ^ 2 = 0
(2^44) ^ 2 = 0
(2^45) ^ 2 = 0
(2^46) ^ 2 = 0
(2^47) ^ 2 = 0
(2^48) ^ 2 = 0
(2^49) ^ 2 = 0
(2^50) ^ 2 = 0
(2^51) ^ 2 = 0
(2^52) ^ 2 = 0
(2^53) ^ 2 = 0
(2^54) ^ 2 = 0
(2^55) ^ 2 = 0
(2^56) ^ 2 = 0
(2^57) ^ 2 = 0
(2^58) ^ 2 = 0
(2^59) ^ 2 = 0
(2^60) ^ 2 = 0
(2^61) ^ 2 = 5316911983139663491615228241121378304
(2^62) ^ 2 = 21267647932558653966460912964485513216
(2^63) ^ 2 = 85070591730234615865843651857942052864
(2^64) ^ 2 = 340282366920938463463374607431768211456
(2^65) ^ 2 = 1361129467683753853853498429727072845824
(2^66) ^ 2 = 5444517870735015415413993718908291383296
(2^67) ^ 2 = 21778071482940061661655974875633165533184
(2^68) ^ 2 = 87112285931760246646623899502532662132736
(2^69) ^ 2 = 348449143727040986586495598010130648530944
(2^70) ^ 2 = 1393796574908163946345982392040522594123776
(2^71) ^ 2 = 5575186299632655785383929568162090376495104
(2^72) ^ 2 = 22300745198530623141535718272648361505980416
(2^73) ^ 2 = 89202980794122492566142873090593446023921664
(2^74) ^ 2 = 356811923176489970264571492362373784095686656
(2^75) ^ 2 = 1427247692705959881058285969449495136382746624
(2^76) ^ 2 = 5708990770823839524233143877797980545530986496
(2^77) ^ 2 = 22835963083295358096932575511191922182123945984
(2^78) ^ 2 = 91343852333181432387730302044767688728495783936
(2^79) ^ 2 = 365375409332725729550921208179070754913983135744
(2^80) ^ 2 = 1461501637330902918203684832716283019655932542976
(2^81) ^ 2 = 5846006549323611672814739330865132078623730171904
(2^82) ^ 2 = 23384026197294446691258957323460528314494920687616
(2^83) ^ 2 = 93536104789177786765035829293842113257979682750464
(2^84) ^ 2 = 374144419156711147060143317175368453031918731001856
(2^85) ^ 2 = 1496577676626844588240573268701473812127674924007424
(2^86) ^ 2 = 5986310706507378352962293074805895248510699696029696
(2^87) ^ 2 = 23945242826029513411849172299223580994042798784118784
(2^88) ^ 2 = 95780971304118053647396689196894323976171195136475136
(2^89) ^ 2 = 383123885216472214589586756787577295904684780545900544
(2^90) ^ 2 = 1532495540865888858358347027150309183618739122183602176
(2^91) ^ 2 = 6129982163463555433433388108601236734474956488734408704
(2^92) ^ 2 = 24519928653854221733733552434404946937899825954937634816
(2^93) ^ 2 = 98079714615416886934934209737619787751599303819750539264
(2^94) ^ 2 = 392318858461667547739736838950479151006397215279002157056
(2^95) ^ 2 = 1569275433846670190958947355801916604025588861116008628224
(2^96) ^ 2 = 6277101735386680763835789423207666416102355444464034512896
(2^97) ^ 2 = 25108406941546723055343157692830665664409421777856138051584
(2^98) ^ 2 = 100433627766186892221372630771322662657637687111424552206336
(2^99) ^ 2 = 401734511064747568885490523085290650630550748445698208825344
(2^100) ^ 2 = 1606938044258990275541962092341162602522202993782792835301376

答案 2 :(得分:3)

我无法重现您运行Arch的结果。

这是我的终端会话日志:

$ uname -r
3.6.10-1-ARCH
$ guile --version
Guile 1.8.8
Copyright (c) 1995, 1996, 1997, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008 Free Software Foundation
Guile may be distributed under the terms of the GNU General Public Licence;
certain other uses are permitted as well.  For details, see the file
`COPYING', which is included in the Guile distribution.
There is no warranty, to the extent permitted by law.
$ guile
guile> (define (square x) (* x x))
guile> (define (even? x) (= (remainder x 2) 0))
guile> (define (expt b n)
        (cond ((= n 0) 1)
            ((even? n) (square (expt b (/ n 2))))
            (else (* b (expt b (- n 1))))))
guile> (expt 2 10)
1024
guile> (expt 2 64)
18446744073709551616
guile> (expt 2 487)
399583814440447005616844445413525287135820562261116307309972090832047582568929999375399181192126972308457847183540047730617340886948900519205142528
guile> (expt 2 488)
799167628880894011233688890827050574271641124522232614619944181664095165137859998750798362384253944616915694367080095461234681773897801038410285056
guile> (expt 2 1000)
10715086071862673209484250490600018105614048117055336074437503883703510511249361224931983788156958581275946729175531468251871452856923140435984577574698574803934567774824230985421074605062371141877954182153046474983581941267398767559165543946077062914571196477686542167660429831652624386837205668069376
guile> (expt 2 10000)
19950631168807583848837421626835850838234968318861924548520089498529438830221946631919961684036194597899331129423209124271556491349413781117593785932096323957855730046793794526765246551266059895520550086918193311542508608460618104685509074866089624888090489894838009253941633257850621568309473902556912388065225096643874441046759871626985453222868538161694315775629640762836880760732228535091641476183956381458969463899410840960536267821064621427333394036525565649530603142680234969400335934316651459297773279665775606172582031407994198179607378245683762280037302885487251900834464581454650557929601414833921615734588139257095379769119277800826957735674444123062018757836325502728323789270710373802866393031428133241401624195671690574061419654342324638801248856147305207431992259611796250130992860241708340807605932320161268492288496255841312844061536738951487114256315111089745514203313820202931640957596464756010405845841566072044962867016515061920631004186422275908670900574606417856951911456055068251250406007519842261898059237118054444788072906395242548339221982707404473162376760846613033778706039803413197133493654622700563169937455508241780972810983291314403571877524768509857276937926433221599399876886660808368837838027643282775172273657572744784112294389733810861607423253291974813120197604178281965697475898164531258434135959862784130128185406283476649088690521047580882615823961985770122407044330583075869039319604603404973156583208672105913300903752823415539745394397715257455290510212310947321610753474825740775273986348298498340756937955646638621874569499279016572103701364433135817214311791398222983845847334440270964182851005072927748364550578634501100852987812389473928699540834346158807043959118985815145779177143619698728131459483783202081474982171858011389071228250905826817436220577475921417653715687725614904582904992461028630081535583308130101987675856234343538955409175623400844887526162643568648833519463720377293240094456246923254350400678027273837755376406726898636241037491410966718557050759098100246789880178271925953381282421954028302759408448955014676668389697996886241636313376393903373455801407636741877711055384225739499110186468219696581651485130494222369947714763069155468217682876200362777257723781365331611196811280792669481887201298643660768551639860534602297871557517947385246369446923087894265948217008051120322365496288169035739121368338393591756418733850510970271613915439590991598154654417336311656936031122249937969999226781732358023111862644575299135758175008199839236284615249881088960232244362173771618086357015468484058622329792853875623486556440536962622018963571028812361567512543338303270029097668650568557157505516727518899194129711337690149916181315171544007728650573189557450920330185304847113818315407324053319038462084036421763703911550639789000742853672196280903477974533320468368795868580237952218629120080742819551317948157624448298518461509704888027274721574688131594750409732115080498190455803416826949787141316063210686391511681774304792596709376
guile> (exit)