Question

基本问题似乎是我无法从内部函数中检索小部件的状态。

我正在尝试使使用与gWidgets2tcltk兼容的gWidgets2RGtk2开发的程序包。该软件包包括一个图形用户界面，实现了保存gui状态的可能性。该代码按使用RGtk2的预期工作，但是使用tcltk存在问题。我尝试了if构造的各种变体。我感到奇怪的是，我可以从.loadState内部读取状态，而不能从.saveState内部读取状态。他们是从不同的地方打电话来的，那么问题可能与环境有关吗？我被困了一段时间，所以也许我对一个显而易见的解决方案视而不见，或者也许有一种更好的方法来完成我要执行的行为。下面的代码说明了这个问题。

我正在Windows 10系统上使用R版本3.5.1，gWidgets2tcltk_1.0-6和gWidgets2_1.0-7。

# The code works as intended using RGtk2.
require(gWidgets2RGtk2)
options("guiToolkit"="RGtk2")

# The code does not work when using tcltk.
# require(gWidgets2tcltk)
# options("guiToolkit" = "tcltk")

saveStateExample <- function(env = parent.frame(), savegui = NULL) {

  # savegui = NULL, Default when started manually as GUI wrapped function.
  # savegui = TRUE, Passed from main GUI when started as part of full program.
  # savegui = FALSE, Passed from main GUI when started as part of full program.


  # Create windows.
  w <- gwindow(title = "Checkbox behaviour", visible = FALSE)

  # Runs when window is closed.
  addHandlerDestroy(w, handler = function(h, ...) {

    # Save GUI state.
    .saveState()
  })

  # Create container.
  g <- ggroup(container = w, expand = TRUE, horizontal = FALSE)

  # Add checkbox to control saving gui statesa.
  save_state_chk <- gcheckbox(text = "Save state", checked = FALSE, container = g)

  # Add a text widget.
  text_edt <- gedit(container = g)

  # Add buttons to manually trigger the functions.
  load_btn <- gbutton(text = "Run .loadState", container = g)
  save_btn <- gbutton(text = "Run .saveState", container = g)

  addHandlerChanged(load_btn, handler = function(h, ...) {

    .loadState()

  })

  addHandlerChanged(save_btn, handler = function(h, ...) {

    .saveState()

  })

  # Internal function ---------------------------------------------------------

  .loadState <- function() {
    message(".loadState")
    message("save_state_chk was ", svalue(save_state_chk))
    message("savegui was ", savegui)

    # First check if save argument was passed.
    if (!is.null(savegui)) {
      # Update widget with passed value.
      svalue(save_state_chk) <- savegui
      message("save_state_chk set to ", savegui)
      message("save_state_chk is ", svalue(save_state_chk))
    } else {
      # Look for previously saved flag.
      if (exists(".package_savegui", envir = env, inherits = FALSE)) {
        svalue(save_state_chk) <- get(".package_savegui", envir = env)
        message(".package_savegui loaded")
      }
    }

    message("LOAD SAVED STATE")

    # Then load settings if true.
    if (svalue(save_state_chk)) {
      if (exists(".package_text", envir = env, inherits = FALSE)) {
        svalue(text_edt) <- get(".package_text", envir = env)
      }

      message("GUI saved state loaded")
    } else {
      message("GUI default state loaded")
    }
  }

  # Internal function ---------------------------------------------------------

  .saveState <- function() {
    message(".saveState")
    message("save_state_chk was ", svalue(save_state_chk))
    message("savegui was ", savegui)

    # First check status of save flag.
    if (is.null(svalue(save_state_chk))) {
      message("save_state_chk=NULL")
    } else {
      message("SAVE STATE")
      # Then save settings if true.
      if (svalue(save_state_chk)) {
        assign(x = ".package_savegui", value = svalue(save_state_chk), envir = env)
        assign(x = ".package_text", value = svalue(text_edt), envir = env)

        message("GUI state saved")
      } else { # or remove all saved values if false.

        if (exists(".package_savegui", envir = env, inherits = FALSE)) {
          remove(".package_savegui", envir = env)
        }
        if (exists(".package_text", envir = env, inherits = FALSE)) {
          remove(".package_text", envir = env)
        }

        message("GUI state cleared")
      }
    }
  }

  # Run internal function to load state before showing window.
  .loadState()
  visible(w) <- TRUE
}

# Open gui.
saveStateExample()

EDIT1：我在下面做了一个最小化的示例，该示例可用于您描述的两种工具包。目的是确保内部功能按预期方式工作。

为了进一步查找问题，我编辑了上面的第一个代码示例，其中包括手动触发内部功能的按钮。按钮起作用，状态可以读取，并且可以通过message功能进行打印。但是，当销毁处理程序被触发时（使用tcltk工具包），该状态仍未读取。似乎使用tcltk工具包破坏了内容为时过早，但没有使用RGtk2工具包破坏了内容。有什么想法吗？

# The code works as intended using RGtk2 and tcltk.
# require(gWidgets2RGtk2)
# options("guiToolkit"="RGtk2")

 require(gWidgets2tcltk)
 options("guiToolkit" = "tcltk")

saveStateExample <- function() {

  # Create windows.
  w <- gwindow(title = "Checkbox behaviour", visible = FALSE)

  # Runs when window is closed.
  addHandlerDestroy(w, handler = function(h, ...) {

    message("Window destroyed")
    message("save_state_chk is ", svalue(save_state_chk))
    message("text_edt is ", svalue(text_edt))

  })

  # Create container.
  g <- ggroup(container = w, expand = TRUE, horizontal = FALSE)

  # Add checkbox to control saving gui statesa.
  save_state_chk <- gcheckbox(text = "Save state", checked = FALSE, container = g)

  # Add a text widget.
  text_edt <- gedit(container = g)

  # Add buttons.
  check_btn <- gbutton(text = "Check", container = g)
  uncheck_btn <- gbutton(text = "UnCheck", container = g)

  addHandlerChanged(check_btn, handler = function(h, ...) {

    .setCheckTrue()

  })

  addHandlerChanged(uncheck_btn, handler = function(h, ...) {

    .setCheckFalse()

  })

  # Internal function ---------------------------------------------------------

  .setCheckTrue <- function() {

    message(".setCheckTrue")
    message("save_state_chk was ", svalue(save_state_chk))

    svalue(save_state_chk) <- TRUE
    message("save_state_chk is ", svalue(save_state_chk))
    message("text_edt is ", svalue(text_edt))

  }

  # Internal function ---------------------------------------------------------

  .setCheckFalse <- function() {

    message(".setCheckFalse")
    message("save_state_chk was ", svalue(save_state_chk))

    svalue(save_state_chk) <- FALSE
    message("save_state_chk is ", svalue(save_state_chk))
    message("text_edt is ", svalue(text_edt))

  }

  # Show window.
  visible(w) <- TRUE

}

# Open gui.
saveStateExample()

EDIT2：感谢您提供@jverzani的提示，我已经按照您的建议尝试了addHandlerUnrealize。这就解决了不读取tcltk的任何值的问题。但是，我花了一些时间来整理内容并使其与两个工具箱一起使用-无法关闭窗口。我在文档中没有找到太多内容，但是通过反复试验，似乎RGtk2和tcltk实施了不同的物流。要继续进行销毁事件，RGtk2需要FALSE，而tcltk需要TRUE。下面是第一个代码示例的固定版本：

# The code now works as intended using both RGtk2 and tcltk!
# require(gWidgets2RGtk2)
# options("guiToolkit"="RGtk2")
require(gWidgets2tcltk)
options("guiToolkit" = "tcltk")

saveStateExample <- function(env = parent.frame(), savegui = NULL) {

  # savegui = NULL, Default when started manually as GUI wrapped function.
  # savegui = TRUE, Passed from main GUI when started as part of full program.
  # savegui = FALSE, Passed from main GUI when started as part of full program.


  # Create windows.
  w <- gwindow(title = "Checkbox behaviour", visible = FALSE)

  # Runs when window is closed.
  addHandlerUnrealize(w, handler = function(h, ...) {

    # Save GUI state.
    .saveState()

    message("UNREALIZE!")

    # Check which toolkit we are using.
    if (gtoolkit() == "tcltk") {
      message("tcltk, returned TRUE!")
      return(TRUE) # Destroys window under tcltk, but not RGtk2.
    } else {
      message("RGtk2, returned FALSE!")
      return(FALSE) # Destroys window under RGtk2, but not with tcltk.
    }
  })

  # Runs when window is closed.
  addHandlerDestroy(w, handler = function(h, ...) {
    message("DESTROY!")
    # addHandlerDestroy does not care of return type for either RGtk2 or tcltk?
  })

  # Create container.
  g <- ggroup(container = w, expand = TRUE, horizontal = FALSE)

  # Add checkbox to control saving gui statesa.
  save_state_chk <- gcheckbox(text = "Save state", checked = FALSE, container = g)

  # Add a text widget.
  text_edt <- gedit(container = g)

  # Add buttons to manually trigger the functions.
  load_btn <- gbutton(text = "Run .loadState", container = g)
  save_btn <- gbutton(text = "Run .saveState", container = g)

  addHandlerChanged(load_btn, handler = function(h, ...) {
    .loadState()
  })

  addHandlerChanged(save_btn, handler = function(h, ...) {
    .saveState()
  })

  # Internal function ---------------------------------------------------------

  .loadState <- function() {
    message(".loadState")
    message("save_state_chk was ", svalue(save_state_chk))
    message("savegui was ", savegui)

    # First check if save argument was passed.
    if (!is.null(savegui)) {
      # Update widget with passed value.
      svalue(save_state_chk) <- savegui
      message("save_state_chk set to ", savegui)
      message("save_state_chk is ", svalue(save_state_chk))
    } else {
      # Look for previously saved flag.
      if (exists(".package_savegui", envir = env, inherits = FALSE)) {
        svalue(save_state_chk) <- get(".package_savegui", envir = env)
        message(".package_savegui loaded")
      }
    }

    message("LOAD SAVED STATE")

    # Then load settings if true.
    if (svalue(save_state_chk)) {
      if (exists(".package_text", envir = env, inherits = FALSE)) {
        svalue(text_edt) <- get(".package_text", envir = env)
      }

      message("GUI saved state loaded")
    } else {
      message("GUI default state loaded")
    }
  }

  # Internal function ---------------------------------------------------------

  .saveState <- function() {
    message(".saveState")
    message("save_state_chk was ", svalue(save_state_chk))
    message("savegui was ", savegui)

    # First check status of save flag.
    if (is.null(svalue(save_state_chk))) {
      message("save_state_chk=NULL")
    } else {
      message("SAVE STATE")
      # Then save settings if true.
      if (svalue(save_state_chk)) {
        assign(x = ".package_savegui", value = svalue(save_state_chk), envir = env)
        assign(x = ".package_text", value = svalue(text_edt), envir = env)

        message("GUI state saved")
      } else { # or remove all saved values if false.

        if (exists(".package_savegui", envir = env, inherits = FALSE)) {
          remove(".package_savegui", envir = env)
        }
        if (exists(".package_text", envir = env, inherits = FALSE)) {
          remove(".package_text", envir = env)
        }

        message("GUI state cleared")
      }
    }
  }

  # Run internal function to load state before showing window.
  .loadState()
  visible(w) <- TRUE
}

# Open gui.
saveStateExample()

Answer 1

问题的原因是addHandlerDestroy不适合保存小部件状态。它可能像RGtk2一样起作用，但是不能保证此时可以访问小部件。解决方法是改为使用addHandlerUnrealize，正如@jverzani在评论中指出的那样：

您应该在这里尝试addHandlerUnrealize（尽管我不知道这是否适用于RGtk2，无法测试）。只要那只要您的处理程序不会返回FALSE，但会在销毁之前执行事件，因此您的窗口小部件仍然可以读取。 – jverzani 1月24日下午16:38

有趣的是，示例代码揭示了用不同的方式来实现信号销毁窗口的实现（有关变通方法，请参见原始文章）。请注意，@ jverzani考虑推送修复程序，它将对此进行更改。

如何在gWidgets2tcltk中检索复选框状态（在gWidgets2RGtk2中有效）

1 个答案: