当我启动包含一组任务和回调的chord()列表时，只有在完成所有任务组后才会调用回调，即使是当前和弦中没有的任务。 / p>
以下是更好解释的代码：
import time
from celery import Celery, group, chord
app = Celery('tasks')
app.config_from_object('celeryconfig')
@app.task(name='SHORT_TASK')
def short_task(t):
time.sleep(t)
return t
@app.task(name='FINISH_GROUP')
def finish_group(res, nb):
print("Pipe #{} finished".format(nb))
return True
@app.task
def main(total):
tasks = []
for nb in range(1, total+1):
short_tasks = [short_task.si(i) for i in [0.5, 0.75, 1]]
chord(
group(short_tasks),
finish_group.s(nb)
).apply_async()
我用5个项目启动它，例如：
In [5]: main.delay(5)
Out[5]: <AsyncResult: db1f97f0-ff7a-4651-b2f9-11e27a001480>
结果：
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,374: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: tasks.main[6da738b5-4eae-4de4-9ac5-1dc67d210f1d]
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,409: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: SHORT_TASK[9581f9e0-1128-4b87-ae6b-16f238b2337e]
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,411: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: SHORT_TASK[579dc498-3770-4385-a25a-06173fbe639c]
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,412: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: SHORT_TASK[bfafb943-46d8-42e3-941f-b48a9c8e0186]
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,414: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: SHORT_TASK[a1208f06-250f-48ac-b3df-45c4525fe8eb]
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,416: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: SHORT_TASK[86ee7408-9d61-4909-bce8-c42cf691e9c2]
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,416: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: SHORT_TASK[e2bb22c0-1d20-4da7-91d9-45b7ed8bfc6f]
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,419: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: SHORT_TASK[7551199b-4690-45dd-a434-3911861f0093]
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,420: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: SHORT_TASK[362d18f4-2252-4a31-ad21-4a2d192fd22e]
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,421: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: SHORT_TASK[7561c33b-7020-4feb-b054-3919e4ae31c2]
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,423: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: SHORT_TASK[3ac997f5-6d0f-43b6-ab15-a6827a26665f]
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,423: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: SHORT_TASK[8b2ebb3a-293c-4bb8-88a3-5242750a082e]
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,423: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-3] Task tasks.main[6da738b5-4eae-4de4-9ac5-1dc67d210f1d] succeeded in 0.048569423001026735s: None
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,424: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: SHORT_TASK[efd68688-ec4a-418d-83b9-a55fd6cc1541]
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,427: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: SHORT_TASK[4e82540e-f935-4288-828f-c6f66f84139a]
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,427: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: SHORT_TASK[a94e4ec4-adcb-4a0f-b184-b36650105ed5]
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,427: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: SHORT_TASK[0d4b5e24-7aaa-4eb8-8e54-70e769dfdb39]
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,918: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-2] Task SHORT_TASK[9581f9e0-1128-4b87-ae6b-16f238b2337e] succeeded in 0.5051485379808582s: 0.5
[2017-11-06 13:50:38,926: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-3] Task SHORT_TASK[a1208f06-250f-48ac-b3df-45c4525fe8eb] succeeded in 0.5012409449846018s: 0.5
[2017-11-06 13:50:39,165: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-1] Task SHORT_TASK[579dc498-3770-4385-a25a-06173fbe639c] succeeded in 0.7524393269850407s: 0.75
[2017-11-06 13:50:39,445: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-4] Task SHORT_TASK[bfafb943-46d8-42e3-941f-b48a9c8e0186] succeeded in 1.031865488999756s: 1
[2017-11-06 13:50:39,448: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: FINISH_GROUP[4506631f-f9cc-4e9e-a9e7-9a59c8f7c998]
[2017-11-06 13:50:39,668: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-1] Task SHORT_TASK[7551199b-4690-45dd-a434-3911861f0093] succeeded in 0.501304400007939s: 0.5
[2017-11-06 13:50:39,672: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-2] Task SHORT_TASK[86ee7408-9d61-4909-bce8-c42cf691e9c2] succeeded in 0.7513346789928619s: 0.75
[2017-11-06 13:50:39,932: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-3] Task SHORT_TASK[e2bb22c0-1d20-4da7-91d9-45b7ed8bfc6f] succeeded in 1.0058077470166609s: 1
[2017-11-06 13:50:39,936: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: FINISH_GROUP[f143d581-799b-45ff-9e11-edc0bb88006a]
[2017-11-06 13:50:40,175: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-2] Task SHORT_TASK[3ac997f5-6d0f-43b6-ab15-a6827a26665f] succeeded in 0.502920284983702s: 0.5
[2017-11-06 13:50:40,198: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-4] Task SHORT_TASK[362d18f4-2252-4a31-ad21-4a2d192fd22e] succeeded in 0.752579735009931s: 0.75
[2017-11-06 13:50:40,685: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-3] Task SHORT_TASK[8b2ebb3a-293c-4bb8-88a3-5242750a082e] succeeded in 0.7518302960088477s: 0.75
[2017-11-06 13:50:40,701: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-4] Task SHORT_TASK[4e82540e-f935-4288-828f-c6f66f84139a] succeeded in 0.5013290829956532s: 0.5
[2017-11-06 13:50:40,715: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-1] Task SHORT_TASK[7561c33b-7020-4feb-b054-3919e4ae31c2] succeeded in 1.0464465210097842s: 1
[2017-11-06 13:50:40,715: WARNING/ForkPoolWorker-1] Pipe #1 finished
[2017-11-06 13:50:40,716: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-1] Task FINISH_GROUP[4506631f-f9cc-4e9e-a9e7-9a59c8f7c998] succeeded in 0.000513697013957426s: True
[2017-11-06 13:50:40,716: WARNING/ForkPoolWorker-1] Pipe #2 finished
[2017-11-06 13:50:40,717: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-1] Task FINISH_GROUP[f143d581-799b-45ff-9e11-edc0bb88006a] succeeded in 0.0003622350050136447s: True
[2017-11-06 13:50:40,718: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: FINISH_GROUP[fc9be8c2-99f7-46b2-a810-47023e0a072a]
[2017-11-06 13:50:40,718: WARNING/ForkPoolWorker-1] Pipe #3 finished
[2017-11-06 13:50:40,718: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-1] Task FINISH_GROUP[fc9be8c2-99f7-46b2-a810-47023e0a072a] succeeded in 0.00038264598697423935s: True
[2017-11-06 13:50:41,215: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-2] Task SHORT_TASK[efd68688-ec4a-418d-83b9-a55fd6cc1541] succeeded in 1.0379863310081419s: 1
[2017-11-06 13:50:41,219: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: FINISH_GROUP[6a4dc66e-2232-4bad-9d85-9fbc63b8b847]
[2017-11-06 13:50:41,221: WARNING/ForkPoolWorker-2] Pipe #4 finished
[2017-11-06 13:50:41,222: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-2] Task FINISH_GROUP[6a4dc66e-2232-4bad-9d85-9fbc63b8b847] succeeded in 0.0018843600118998438s: True
[2017-11-06 13:50:41,440: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-3] Task SHORT_TASK[a94e4ec4-adcb-4a0f-b184-b36650105ed5] succeeded in 0.7531412789830938s: 0.75
[2017-11-06 13:50:41,708: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-4] Task SHORT_TASK[0d4b5e24-7aaa-4eb8-8e54-70e769dfdb39] succeeded in 1.005872479028767s: 1
[2017-11-06 13:50:41,711: INFO/MainProcess] Received task: FINISH_GROUP[388ee1c3-b80c-41af-bbfd-29b968e90aff]
[2017-11-06 13:50:41,712: WARNING/ForkPoolWorker-3] Pipe #5 finished
[2017-11-06 13:50:41,712: INFO/ForkPoolWorker-3] Task FINISH_GROUP[388ee1c3-b80c-41af-bbfd-29b968e90aff] succeeded in 0.0005500270053744316s: True
我推出了一个并发的Celery：4（prefork）。
我们可以在开始时看到已收到15个SHORT_TASK，然后工作人员执行它，并且只有在调用FINISH_GROUP任务之后才会执行它。
是否可以在关联的 SHORT_TASK完成后启动FINISH_GROUP任务，而不是等待所有其他不相关的SHORT_TASK？
也许我的画布不正确，或者它是一个错误的芹菜配置，我不知道。
感谢您的帮助！
答案 0 :(得分：2)
您的测试有biais，因为您只使用一名工作人员，time.sleep()将阻止该工作人员。这意味着它即使在4处并发也不会处理任何任务。
是否可以在关联的SHORT_TASK完成后启动FINISH_GROUP任务，而不是等待所有其他不相关的SHORT_TASK？
目前您还没有等待其他short_task完成，它们都计划在同一时间执行。由于您正在使用睡眠状态，因此finish_group会在其各个和弦的所有short_task结束后被调用。
您当前的执行情况如下：
| chord 1 | chord 2 | chord 3 |
|--------------|--------------|--------------|
| short_task 1 | | | |
| | short_task 1 | | |
| | | short_task 1 | |
| short_task 2 | | | |
| | short_task 2 | | |
| | | short_task 2 | |
| short_task 3 | | | v
| | short_task 3 | | execution order
| | | short_task 3 |
| finish_group | | |
| | finish_group | |
| | | finish_group |
如果删除睡眠，请添加更多工作者，或使用gevent。它应该是这样的：
| chord 1 | chord 2 | chord 3 |
|------------------|------------------|------------- ----|
| short_task 1,2,3 | short_task 1,2,3 | short_task 1,2,3 |
| finish_group | finish_group | finish_group |
你应该看到同一行上的任务将在日志中显示（取决于哪个工作人员首先使用它）不同的顺序。但finish_group仍将是最后一次。
请注意，使用group
chord您的任务
chord(
short_tasks,
finish_group.s(nb)
)
相同的代码，但有gevent：
import gevent
from celery import Celery, group, chord, chain
app = Celery('tasks', broker='redis://localhost/4', backend='redis://localhost/5')
@app.task()
def short_task(nb, i):
print('TEST: start short_task({}, {})'.format(nb, i))
gevent.sleep(1)
print('TEST: end short_task({}, {})'.format(nb, i))
return i
@app.task(name='FINISH_GROUP')
def finish_group(results, nb):
print('TEST: finish_group({}) -> {}'.format(nb, results))
@app.task
def main(total):
for nb in range(1, total+1):
short_tasks = [short_task.si(nb, i) for i in range(3)]
chord(short_tasks, finish_group.s(nb)).apply_async()
启动：
$ celery worker -A celery_test --loglevel=debug --concurrency=20 -P gevent 2>&1 | grep TEST
由于执行并行，输出将被加扰。
[2017-11-06 16:40:08,085] TEST: start short_task(1, 0)
[2017-11-06 16:40:08,088] TEST: start short_task(1, 1)
[2017-11-06 16:40:08,091] TEST: start short_task(1, 2)
[2017-11-06 16:40:08,092] TEST: start short_task(2, 0)
[2017-11-06 16:40:08,094] TEST: start short_task(2, 1)
[2017-11-06 16:40:08,096] TEST: start short_task(2, 2)
[2017-11-06 16:40:08,100] TEST: start short_task(3, 0)
[2017-11-06 16:40:08,101] TEST: start short_task(3, 1)
[2017-11-06 16:40:08,103] TEST: start short_task(3, 2)
# ^ all short_task have been started at the same time
[2017-11-06 16:40:09,085] TEST: end short_task(1, 0)
[2017-11-06 16:40:09,089] TEST: end short_task(1, 1)
[2017-11-06 16:40:09,093] TEST: end short_task(1, 2)
[2017-11-06 16:40:09,106] TEST: end short_task(2, 0)
[2017-11-06 16:40:09,106] TEST: end short_task(2, 1)
[2017-11-06 16:40:09,107] TEST: end short_task(2, 2)
[2017-11-06 16:40:09,107] TEST: end short_task(3, 0)
[2017-11-06 16:40:09,108] TEST: end short_task(3, 1)
[2017-11-06 16:40:09,108] TEST: end short_task(3, 2)
# ^ total execution is only 1 second since 9 greenlet have slept together
[2017-11-06 16:40:09,115] TEST: finish_group(1) -> [0, 1, 2]
[2017-11-06 16:40:09,126] TEST: finish_group(2) -> [2, 1, 0]
[2017-11-06 16:40:09,128] TEST: finish_group(3) -> [0, 1, 2]
# ^ order of results are mixed depending of which greenlet finished first