我正在尝试在Go中编写一个通知结构，该结构将保存一系列键及其各自的值，并在值低于阈值时触发通知。
通知仅应触发一次，当第一个样本降至阈值以下时，通知中的其他样本不应再次触发，直到该值上升到阈值之上。
例如，假设我的阈值为10，并且我发送了15、14、11、10，... 9的样本。一旦发送了9，应该发出通知。进一步的8、7、4样本不应引起任何影响。以下样本（例如5、6、7、9、10、11、14、30）不应采取任何措施。一旦样本再次降至10：30、20、15、10、7 ...以下，则必须发送另一个通知。
当多个goroutine操纵我的结构时，我遇到了问题。
我尝试使用sync.Mutex进行同步，并且还使用了sync.Map，但是没有运气。我感觉某个地方有参考副本或缓存，但是我在Go语言中太新了，无法发现问题。
为此，我创建了一个像这样的结构：
type Notifier interface {
Send(message string)
}
type NotificationBoard struct {
mutex sync.Mutex
Last sync.Map
notifier Notifier
}
func (n *NotificationBoard) Init(notifier Notifier) {
n.notifier = notifier
}
// NotifyLess ...
func (n *NotificationBoard) NotifyLess(key string, value, threshold float64) {
n.mutex.Lock()
defer n.mutex.Unlock()
if value >= threshold {
fmt.Printf("NotificationBoard.NotifyLess %v (value >= threshold): %v >= %v\n", key, value, threshold)
n.Last.Store(key, value)
return
}
// value < threshold
if last, found := n.Last.Load(key); found == true {
fmt.Printf("NotificationBoard.NotifyLess %v (value < threshold): %v < %v : found %v\n", key, value, threshold, last)
if last.(float64) >= threshold { // first trigger
n.notifier.Send(fmt.Sprintf("%s < %v (%v)", key, threshold, value))
}
} else {
fmt.Printf("NotificationBoard.NotifyLess %v (value < threshold): %v < %v : not found\n", key, value, threshold)
// not found, started board as less
n.notifier.Send(fmt.Sprintf("%s < %v (%v)", key, threshold, value))
}
n.Last.Store(key, value)
return
}
我知道使用sync.Mutex或sync.Map就足够了，但是上面的代码同时具有这两个功能，因为它是我当前的（损坏的）版本。
为了进行测试，我设置了以下代码：
type dummy struct{}
func (d *dummy) Send(message string) {
fmt.Println("--------------> notifying", message)
}
func newBoard() *NotificationBoard {
notificationBoard := &NotificationBoard{}
notificationBoard.Init(&dummy{})
return notificationBoard
}
我还添加了一些fmt.Println跟踪（为简便起见，未包含在上面的代码中），并且首先准备了单gouroutine测试（按预期工作）：
func Test1(t *testing.T) {
board := newBoard()
board.NotifyLess("k1", 15, 10)
board.NotifyLess("k1", 10, 10)
board.NotifyLess("k1", 5, 10)
board.NotifyLess("k1", 4, 10)
board.NotifyLess("k1", 3, 10)
board.NotifyLess("k1", 10, 10)
board.NotifyLess("k1", 15, 10)
board.NotifyLess("k1", 20, 10)
board.NotifyLess("k1", 15, 10)
board.NotifyLess("k1", 10, 10)
board.NotifyLess("k1", 5, 10)
board.NotifyLess("k1", 1, 10)
}
输出：
> go test -run Test1
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess k1 (value >= threshold): 15 >= 10
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess k1 (value >= threshold): 10 >= 10
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess k1 (value < threshold): 5 < 10 : found 10
--------------> notifying k1 < 10 (5)
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess k1 (value < threshold): 4 < 10 : found 5
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess k1 (value < threshold): 3 < 10 : found 4
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess k1 (value >= threshold): 10 >= 10
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess k1 (value >= threshold): 15 >= 10
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess k1 (value >= threshold): 20 >= 10
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess k1 (value >= threshold): 15 >= 10
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess k1 (value >= threshold): 10 >= 10
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess k1 (value < threshold): 5 < 10 : found 10
--------------> notifying k1 < 10 (5)
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess k1 (value < threshold): 1 < 10 : found 5
PASS
我们可以看到输出“ notify ....”发生两次，仅在样本降至阈值以下的时刻
但是随后，我创建了一个多gouroutine测试，然后通知发生了多次：
func Test3(t *testing.T) {
preparing := sync.WaitGroup{}
preparing.Add(1)
board := newBoard()
wg := sync.WaitGroup{}
for i := 0; i < 30; i++ {
wg.Add(1)
go func(x int, not *NotificationBoard) {
fmt.Printf("routine %v waiting preparation... \n", x)
preparing.Wait()
for j := 15.0; j > 5; j-- {
fmt.Printf("routine %v notifying %v\n", x, j)
not.NotifyLess("keyX", j+float64(x+1)/100, 10)
}
wg.Done()
}(i, board)
}
preparing.Done()
wg.Wait()
}
输出：
> go test -run Test3
routine 7 waiting preparation...
routine 2 waiting preparation...
routine 2 notifying 15
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 15.03 >= 10
routine 2 notifying 14
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 14.03 >= 10
routine 2 notifying 13
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 13.03 >= 10
routine 2 notifying 12
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 12.03 >= 10
routine 2 notifying 11
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 11.03 >= 10
routine 2 notifying 10
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 10.03 >= 10
routine 2 notifying 9
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 9.03 < 10 : found 10.03
--------------> notifying keyX < 10 (9.03)
routine 2 notifying 8
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 8.03 < 10 : found 9.03
routine 2 notifying 7
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 7.03 < 10 : found 8.03
routine 2 notifying 6
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 6.03 < 10 : found 7.03
routine 14 waiting preparation...
routine 14 notifying 15
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 15.15 >= 10
routine 14 notifying 14
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 14.15 >= 10
routine 14 notifying 13
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 13.15 >= 10
routine 14 notifying 12
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 12.15 >= 10
routine 14 notifying 11
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 11.15 >= 10
routine 14 notifying 10
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 10.15 >= 10
routine 14 notifying 9
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 9.15 < 10 : found 10.15
--------------> notifying keyX < 10 (9.15)
routine 14 notifying 8
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 8.15 < 10 : found 9.15
routine 14 notifying 7
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 7.15 < 10 : found 8.15
routine 14 notifying 6
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 6.15 < 10 : found 7.15
routine 22 waiting preparation...
routine 27 waiting preparation...
routine 27 notifying 15
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 15.28 >= 10
routine 27 notifying 14
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 14.28 >= 10
routine 27 notifying 13
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 13.28 >= 10
routine 27 notifying 12
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 12.28 >= 10
routine 27 notifying 11
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 11.28 >= 10
routine 27 notifying 10
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 10.28 >= 10
routine 27 notifying 9
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 9.28 < 10 : found 10.28
--------------> notifying keyX < 10 (9.28)
routine 27 notifying 8
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 8.28 < 10 : found 9.28
routine 27 notifying 7
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 7.28 < 10 : found 8.28
routine 27 notifying 6
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 6.28 < 10 : found 7.28
routine 20 waiting preparation...
routine 20 notifying 15
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 15.21 >= 10
routine 20 notifying 14
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 14.21 >= 10
routine 20 notifying 13
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 13.21 >= 10
routine 20 notifying 12
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 12.21 >= 10
routine 20 notifying 11
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 11.21 >= 10
routine 20 notifying 10
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 10.21 >= 10
routine 20 notifying 9
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 9.21 < 10 : found 10.21
--------------> notifying keyX < 10 (9.21)
routine 20 notifying 8
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 8.21 < 10 : found 9.21
routine 20 notifying 7
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 7.21 < 10 : found 8.21
routine 20 notifying 6
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 6.21 < 10 : found 7.21
routine 19 waiting preparation...
routine 19 notifying 15
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 15.2 >= 10
routine 19 notifying 14
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 14.2 >= 10
routine 19 notifying 13
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 13.2 >= 10
routine 19 notifying 12
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 12.2 >= 10
routine 19 notifying 11
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 11.2 >= 10
routine 19 notifying 10
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 10.2 >= 10
routine 19 notifying 9
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 9.2 < 10 : found 10.2
--------------> notifying keyX < 10 (9.2)
routine 19 notifying 8
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 8.2 < 10 : found 9.2
routine 19 notifying 7
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 7.2 < 10 : found 8.2
routine 19 notifying 6
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 6.2 < 10 : found 7.2
routine 0 waiting preparation...
routine 0 notifying 15
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 15.01 >= 10
routine 0 notifying 14
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 14.01 >= 10
routine 0 notifying 13
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 13.01 >= 10
routine 0 notifying 12
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 12.01 >= 10
routine 0 notifying 11
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 11.01 >= 10
routine 0 notifying 10
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 10.01 >= 10
routine 0 notifying 9
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 9.01 < 10 : found 10.01
--------------> notifying keyX < 10 (9.01)
routine 0 notifying 8
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 8.01 < 10 : found 9.01
routine 0 notifying 7
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 7.01 < 10 : found 8.01
routine 0 notifying 6
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 6.01 < 10 : found 7.01
routine 17 waiting preparation...
routine 17 notifying 15
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 15.18 >= 10
routine 17 notifying 14
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 14.18 >= 10
routine 17 notifying 13
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 13.18 >= 10
routine 17 notifying 12
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 12.18 >= 10
routine 17 notifying 11
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 11.18 >= 10
routine 17 notifying 10
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 10.18 >= 10
routine 17 notifying 9
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 9.18 < 10 : found 10.18
--------------> notifying keyX < 10 (9.18)
routine 17 notifying 8
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 8.18 < 10 : found 9.18
routine 17 notifying 7
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 7.18 < 10 : found 8.18
routine 17 notifying 6
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 6.18 < 10 : found 7.18
routine 15 waiting preparation...
routine 16 waiting preparation...
...... continues
我添加了一个十进制值来表示goroutine，然后查看输出，似乎每个goroutine都有它自己的映射副本，因为他们正在查找具有相同小数位的前一个值。但后来我发现：
...
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 10.22 >= 10
routine 21 notifying 9
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 10.07 >= 10
routine 6 notifying 9
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 9.08 < 10 : found 10.07
--------------> notifying keyX < 10 (9.08)
routine 7 notifying 8
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 9.17 < 10 : found 9.08
routine 16 notifying 8
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value >= threshold): 10.11 >= 10
routine 10 notifying 9
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 9.3 < 10 : found 10.11
--------------> notifying keyX < 10 (9.3)
routine 29 notifying 8
NotificationBoard.NotifyLess keyX (value < threshold): 9.19 < 10 : found 9.3
routine 18 notifying 8
...
这表明他们还从其他goroutine中找到了先前的值。
我很确定这是一个基本的并发问题，但是我找不到它。 ：（
我正在使用：
> go version
go version go1.10.2 windows/amd64
任何想法？